Historic Baseball

The 1985 Royals: A Controversial Call and a Comeback

The 1985 Kansas City Royals remain a cornerstone of Major League Baseball history for both their remarkable come-from-behind performance in the World Series and the controversial call in Game 6 that left an indelible mark on the series’ narrative. The Royals, who were relative underdogs facing the formidable St. Louis Cardinals, embarked on a journey that was fraught with challenges, yet ultimately led them to an unforgettable triumph. This team, driven by a mix of veteran leadership and youthful exuberance, captured the hearts of fans nationwide. The 1985 season was not just about winning the title; it was about overcoming adversity and carving out a legacy that still resonates in the baseball world today. As we delve deeper, we’ll explore how the events unfolded, examine the controversy that ignited debates for decades, and celebrate the resilience that defined the Royals’ championship run.

The journey of the 1985 Royals to the World Series title was a saga of persistence, skill, and a bit of fortuitous happenstance. They displayed tenacity throughout the regular season and playoffs, navigating through tough opponents and demonstrating a winning spirit. However, it was the World Series, the pinnacle of baseball competitions, where their legacy was truly crafted. This series is remembered not only for the baseball played but for the iconic and enigmatic moments that tested the rules of the game and the nerves of its participants. The Royals’ ability to stay unfazed by controversies illustrates their commendable poise and resolution. In this article, we will recapture the essence of the 1985 Royals’ journey, focusing on the key moments and the lasting impact of their win.

The Path to the World Series

The Kansas City Royals’ 1985 season started with a sense of cautious optimism. Having last reached the World Series in 1980, the Royals were eager to shake off their reputation as a team that couldn’t quite clinch the title. Managed by Dick Howser, the Royals boasted a solid mix of seasoned veterans like George Brett and up-and-coming talents such as Bret Saberhagen. The recipe for their success included stellar pitching, effective hitting, and a sturdy defense. While the Royals didn’t dominate the regular season, they managed a respectable finish with a record of 91-71, topping the American League West Division. This division win set them on a collision course with the Toronto Blue Jays in the American League Championship Series (ALCS).

The ALCS was a grueling, hard-fought battle that saw the Royals down three games to one. In a demonstration of unyielding determination, they clawed their way back to win the ALCS in seven games, a feat that showcased their resiliency. Crucial performances from players like Hal McRae and Bret Saberhagen were instrumental in their success, providing the momentum swing that would propel them forward. Emerging victorious from the ALCS highlighted the Royals’ ability to excel under pressure, reaffirming their position as true contenders for the championship.

The World Series Drama Unfolds

The 1985 World Series was set up to be an intense contest between the Kansas City Royals and the St. Louis Cardinals, known as the I-70 Series after the interstate highway linking the two Missouri cities. It was a classic matchup featuring contrasting styles of play, the Royals’ strong pitching lining up against the Cardinals’ explosive offense. The Cardinals took an early lead in the series, winning three of the first four games, setting up a scenario that required the Royals to rally once again if they were to have any hope of winning the title.

Game 5 saw the Royals ignite their comeback spirit. Anchored by the pitching prowess of Danny Jackson, the Royals secured a crucial victory, keeping their World Series dreams alive. As tension heightened, it became abundantly clear that Game 6 would be pivotal. Trailing in the series 3-2, the Royals needed a victory to force a deciding Game 7. It was this game, captured in the annals of baseball history, where controversy reared its head in the form of a now-infamous call that would become one of the most debated moments in MLB history.

The Controversial Call in Game 6

Game 6 of the 1985 World Series between the Royals and the Cardinals is forever etched into baseball folklore due to an umpiring decision that changed the course of history. The bottom of the ninth inning was where all the action and controversy centered. The Cardinals were leading 1-0, and just three outs from clinching the championship. With Jorge Orta at bat for the Royals, he hit a routine grounder to Cardinals’ first baseman Jack Clark, who tossed it to pitcher Todd Worrell covering the bag. The umpire, Don Denkinger, called Orta safe at first base, a decision which replays showed to be incorrect as Orta was, in all probability, out.

The erroneous call had an instantaneous ripple effect. Manager Whitey Herzog of the Cardinals and his players erupted in protest, but Denkinger’s decision stood as the safe call. This contentious play initiated a chain reaction: the Royals capitalized on the situation, as a subsequent series of hits and a critical passed ball allowed them to score two runs, reclaiming the game and forcing a Game 7. The call was significant, casting a shadow over the Cardinals’ spirits and affecting their composure for the remainder of the series. Denkinger’s call became a touchstone for discussions about umpiring in baseball and eventually contributed to the future implementation of instant replay systems in MLB.

The aftermath of Game 6 was fraught with tension and intensifying rivalry. For the Cardinals, it was a bitter pill to swallow, marinating in the sting of what was viewed as a championship stolen by an umpiring error. For the Royals, however, it was the validation of their resolve and a testament to their ability to seize opportunities, however they presented themselves. The mood of the Series had shifted, adding an additional layer of drama and anticipation to the final game.

Triumphant Comeback: Game 7

Saturated with the emotions and intensity born from Game 6, the Royals entered Game 7 with renewed vigor. Encouraged by their newfound momentum and the psychological advantage from having seized the previous game in stunning fashion, the Royals were primed for glory. The star of Game 7 was Bret Saberhagen, whose dominant pitching cemented his place in World Series lore. He delivered one of the greatest performances by pitching a complete game shutout, effectively stifling the Cardinals’ hitters.

The Royals offense came alive as well, feeding off the overwhelming energy of the home crowd at Royals Stadium. They pummeled the Cardinals, securing an 11-0 victory to claim their first World Series championship. Contributions came from all corners of the team—key players throughout the lineup made instrumental plays that demonstrated the cohesion and team spirit that guided them this far. Bret Saberhagen earned the World Series Most Valuable Player award, highlighting his crucial role in the Royals’ success.

Impact and Legacy of the 1985 Royals

The 1985 Kansas City Royals’ World Series victory holds lasting significance in the annals of baseball history, characterized by its backdrop of drama, controversy, and an impressive comeback narrative. These elements combined to frame a championship that was celebrated not just for its athletic achievement, but for how it tested the foundational elements of sportsmanship: fairness, resilience, and the indomitable will to win. The Royals’ win also brought attention to the need for regulatory advancements in umpiring decisions, an issue that gasped for attention until the gradual implementation of modern technologies and rules that allow for play reviews. Thus, the 1985 Royals indirectly shaped future directives in baseball officiating, highlighting the balance between human error and technological aids in sports.

Beyond the technical repercussions, the Royals’ championship exuded inspiration for teams worldwide, embodying the ‘never give up’ mantra. Their tale encouraged teams and athletes, underscoring that adverse calls and difficult situations could be countered with perseverance, teamwork, and a touch of self-belief. As for the Royals, this triumph remains a golden chapter in their franchise history, giving them their first taste of ultimate glory in the baseball world and transforming a generation of fans into lifelong supporters, nostalgic for the seismic event that was 1985. This championship was the summit of Kansas City’s baseball achievements, creating memories that linger in the hearts of fans for decades.

Conclusion

The saga of the 1985 Kansas City Royals presents a captivating narrative engrossed in triumph over adversity, accentuated by the poignant storylines of a controversial call and a legendary comeback. Their journey to the top was punctuated by defining moments of determination, the influences of error, and ultimately, the essence of victory that characterizes the rich tapestry of sports history. The juxtaposition of being nearly defeated and then prevailing spectacularly imparts invaluable lessons in resilience, impacting sports culture and fan perspectives on the game.

The 1985 Royals will forever be remembered as the team that overcame not only an imposing opponent but the weight of controversial circumstances, ensuring their place in the upper echelons of baseball lore. This World Series, highlighted by the complexities of human error and the tenacity of human spirit, left legacies beyond their first World Series win. It illustrates the perseverance necessary to claim victory and solidifies the Royals as epitomes of tenacity and champions of the game, reminding us that often the most exciting victories are written in the margins of unpredictability and courage under pressure.

As we reflect on their achievements, the 1985 Kansas City Royals remain etched in the annals of baseball as champions who not only reached the pinnacle of success but did so in a way that defined an era, crafted enduring memories, and perhaps most importantly, taught fans and players alike about the potential of the human spirit when faced with daunting odds. Their victory is not just a statistic or a year remembered in plaques, but an embodiment of the spirit of baseball itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What was the controversial call in Game 6 of the 1985 World Series, and why was it significant?

The controversial call in Game 6 of the 1985 World Series is infamous in baseball history and often referred to by fans and historians alike. Late in the game, the Kansas City Royals were trailing the St. Louis Cardinals, and it seemed the Cardinals might clinch the series. In the bottom of the ninth inning, the Royals’ Jorge Orta hit a routine ground ball to the first baseman. The throw to the pitcher covering first base appeared to beat Orta by a small margin. However, umpire Don Denkinger called Orta safe, sparking outrage from the Cardinals and their fans.

This call was significant because it was a pivotal moment that shifted the momentum of the game—and ultimately the series. The Royals capitalized on the controversial call, rallying to win Game 6 with a series of hits and errors from the Cardinals. The call has been dissected over the years for its accuracy—and in an era before instant replay, it left an undeniable impact on the course of MLB history by swaying the outcome of the series.

2. How did the Kansas City Royals manage to stage a comeback to win the 1985 World Series?

The Kansas City Royals’ comeback in the 1985 World Series is a story of resilience and determination. Entering the series as underdogs against the St. Louis Cardinals, the Royals faced numerous challenges, both on the field and within their own team dynamics. The pivotal moment was the controversial call in Game 6, but the Royals’ ability to exploit this opportunity showcased their tactical gameplay and mental fortitude. From there, they used their momentum to clinch Game 7 decisively, with a score of 11-0, sealing their first World Series championship.

Key players like George Brett, Bret Saberhagen, and Frank White brought their A-game, with Saberhagen also being named the World Series MVP. The Royals’ mix of veteran leadership, such as Brett’s calm under pressure, and the youthful exuberance of players like Saberhagen, who was only 21 at the time, contributed significantly to their success. Their path to victory was fueled by a blend of strategic hitting, pitching dominance, and a passionate fan base at Royals Stadium eager to celebrate their team’s triumph.

3. Why were the Kansas City Royals considered underdogs in the 1985 World Series?

The Kansas City Royals were regarded as underdogs during the 1985 World Series largely due to their opponents, the St. Louis Cardinals, who had a rich history of success in Major League Baseball and were a formidable team that year. The Cardinals boasted a roster filled with talent and had showcased robust performances throughout the regular season and playoffs.

In contrast, the Royals, though a strong team in their own right, had experienced their share of ups and downs during the season. Questions surrounding their ability to handle pressure on such a grand stage, especially against a well-seasoned team like the Cardinals, added to the perception of them being underdogs. However, what the Royals may have lacked in prior World Series experience, they compensated for with heart, perseverance, and strategic plays that eventually led them to stun their skeptics and claim the championship.

4. What role did veteran leadership and youthful energy play in the Royals’ World Series win?

The balance of veteran leadership and youthful energy was crucial to the Kansas City Royals’ success in the 1985 World Series. Veterans like George Brett, whose previous postseason experience and calm demeanor provided stability and leadership in the clubhouse and on the field, played an instrumental role in guiding the team through the pressures of the postseason.

Simultaneously, the youthful exuberance and talent of players like Bret Saberhagen energized the team. Saberhagen’s pitching was instrumental; he delivered clutch performances that earned him the World Series MVP honors. The blend of seasoned players and fresh prospects created a dynamic that allowed the Royals to adapt, persevere, and ultimately triumph. This mix of experience and new energy was a fundamental factor in the team’s come-from-behind victory against the Cardinals.

5. How has the 1985 World Series influenced Major League Baseball post-1985?

The 1985 World Series has had a lasting impact on Major League Baseball, particularly concerning the conversation around officiating and the eventual introduction of instant replay technology. The controversial call in Game 6 by umpire Don Denkinger added urgency to the discussion about incorporating replay reviews to ensure accuracy in officiating—though it would not be until several decades later that replay was officially adopted.

Additionally, the Royals’ victory is an enduring reminder of the unpredictability of baseball, illustrating the power of perseverance and the potential for underdogs to achieve success. It reinforced the narrative that a team’s destiny could be altered by a single moment while also showcasing the passion and excitement that postseason baseball can bring. The 1985 Royals remain a symbol of hope and tenacity in the annals of baseball history, encouraging teams and fans to never count out the improbable.